What a site supervisor should do when a worker refuses an alcohol test

6 min read

Alcohol testing before arriving for work or starting a task may be run for work where judgment and physical reactions are directly tied to safety, such as driving vehicles, operating heavy equipment, or working at height. On site, the moment a worker says in front of the breathalyzer that they will not take the test, you have to handle both the fact that alcohol status could not be confirmed and that day's work assignment.

The site supervisor's role here is not to presume that the worker has been drinking or to settle any penalty on the spot. The priority is to make sure a worker whose test is not complete is not put straight into the scheduled high-risk work, to take down the reason the worker gives to the extent needed, and to pass it accurately to the person responsible for the assignment and follow-up decisions.

First connect the incomplete test to the work assignment

When a worker refuses the test, first check whether the work they were scheduled to do that day is high-risk work for which the worksite has a separate verification procedure. If pre-work check criteria are set, as for driving vehicles, operating equipment, or work with fall or caught-in hazards, inform the site manager or the person authorized to approve assignments that the test has not been completed and what work was scheduled. Route the decision on whether to hold off the start of work, have the worker wait, or give them other work so that it is made according to the procedures and authority set in advance.

What you pass on should be limited to confirmed facts. Rather than "they appear to have been drinking," say "the test has not been completed, so the assignment decision for the scheduled work is still pending." The fact that someone did not take the test does not by itself tell you whether they have been drinking or why they refused.

The site supervisor can tell the worker clearly which work they must not start for now and who will give the next instructions. On the other hand, forced testing, allowing an alternative verification method, and HR penalties are not things to decide on the spot. Without this distinction, the response to the same situation can vary with each supervisor's personal judgment.

Do not press for reasons in public

The background to a test refusal cannot be reduced to one thing. The worker may be hearing about the procedure for the first time and want an explanation, may say they have difficulty performing a breath test, or may be concerned about who sees the results and how long they are kept. Rather than asking the worker to describe health or privacy-related circumstances in detail in the queue or on the work floor, it is appropriate to offer a separate space or a private way to get in touch and hear the necessary explanation there.

In the record, write down what the worker actually said separately from questions that have not yet been answered. For example, record "I have difficulty doing a breath test" as a statement about difficulty performing the test, without the supervisor adding a guessed illness or cause. Record "I don't know where the results are kept" as an inquiry about the use and retention of results, and do not interpret it as an attempt to hide drinking.

What to distinguish on site Facts to record Who makes the next decision
Test status Whether the worker refused before the test or stopped partway through Site manager or person authorized to approve assignments
Explanation the worker gave Whether it is a question about the procedure, difficulty performing a breath test, or concern about use of results Safety and health, HR, or privacy department
Same-day work measures Scheduled work, whether the worker is waiting, actual assignment Person authorized to approve assignments

Making these distinctions means the next person in charge does not have to ask for the same explanation again. Instead of evaluative terms such as "noncompliant" or "uncooperative," record at what stage the test stopped and what the worker asked, so the basis for follow-up decisions does not get blurred.

Separate on-site measures from follow-up decisions

What the site supervisor should do right away is guide the worker so that high-risk work does not start, and pass the situation to the designated contacts. For example, if driving was scheduled, tell the person with authority to confirm or change vehicle dispatch about the incomplete test, the scheduled work, and the explanation the worker gave. Also record the time you made contact and the waiting or work restrictions you told the worker about until a decision is made.

On the other hand, HR action for refusing the test, or whether an alternative verification is possible, is not for the site supervisor to conclude. If there are company standards, the department that manages them reviews whether they apply; if there are none, the matter goes to the safety and health, HR, and privacy departments as a procedure to be put in order. Telling the worker who will answer and when to expect a reply reduces situations where they explain their reasons and are then left waiting with no information.

Set the order with a hypothetical night-shift case

Suppose that on a night shift, a worker scheduled to drive a forklift says during the arrival check, "I'm not taking the test because I don't know where the results are kept." The facts observed here are that there is no reading and that the worker asked about the retention and use of results. Interpreting this as suspected drinking or a deliberate refusal goes beyond the observed facts.

A possible action is to hold off the start of forklift driving and inform the person authorized to approve assignments of the scheduled work and the incomplete test. At the same time, pass the question about viewing and retaining results to the department that runs the checks or handles privacy, and tell the worker who will answer and when. The completion criterion in this case is not whether the worker immediately agreed to be tested but a state where the high-risk work assignment has been settled by a decision of someone with authority, and the question, the information given, and the owner of each remaining decision are recorded.

Repeated refusals are clues for fixing the operating procedure

If the same type of refusal keeps recurring, you need to look at the notices and operating flow rather than treating each case only as an individual problem. If workers on each shift keep reacting as though they are hearing about the purpose of testing or the scope of result use for the first time, you can review whether the advance notice was sufficient. If explanations of difficulty performing a breath test recur at a particular time or place, you can also look at the check location and order of steps, without collecting individual health information.

Article 36 of Korea's Occupational Safety and Health Act requires employers to identify hazards and risk factors arising from work, assess the risks, and establish and implement improvement measures to prevent danger or health impairment. The response to alcohol test refusals can also be reviewed as a procedure to reduce gaps in high-risk work assignments and confusion on site. If you improve the notice wording and contact routes based on the questions, contact delays, and gaps in assignment decisions found in repeated cases, you reduce the chance that supervisors will rely on guesswork or improvised persuasion the next time.

References

#workplace alcohol check #work assignment
#test refusal
#site supervisor
Considering our products?
We'll help you decide.